givesyounothing
to
gainbutmartyrdom,
and
inthe
processalot
ofpeople
whodonotbelieve
in
yourcausewilldie.Weaknessisno
sin,
andcanevenbecomeastrength
if
youlearnhowtoplay
itright.
HadtheMelianssurrenderedinthefirstplace,they
wouldhavebeenabletosabotage
theAtheniansinsubtle
ways,ormight
havegotten
whatthey
couldhaveout
ofthe
allianceandthenleftitwhentheAtheniansthemselveswere
weakened,as
infacthappened
several
yearslater.Fortunes
change
andthemighty
areoftenbrought
down.Surrenderconceals
greatpower:Lullingthe
enemyintocomplacency,
itgivesyou
timeto
recoup,
timetoundermine,
timefor
revenge.Neversacrificethattime
inexchange
forhonor
inabattle
that
youcannot
win.Weak
peoplenever
givewaywhen
theyoughtto.Cardinaltle
R212,
16]3-16 79OBSERVANCE
OFTHELAWSometime
in
the
19205
theGermanwriterBertoltBrechtbecameaconverttothecauseofCommunism.Fromthenonhisplays,essays,
and
poemsre-flected
hisrevolutionary
fervor,andhegenerally
triedtomakehisideolog-
ical statements as clear aspossible.
When Hitler came to
powerinGermany,
BrechtandhisCommunistcolleagues
becamemarkedmen.Hehad
many
friendsintheUnitedStates—Amerlcanswhosympathized
withhisbeliefs,
aswellasfellowGermanintellectualswhohadliedHitler.In1941,
accordingly,
Brechtemigrated
totheUnited
States,andchosetoset-tleinLosAngeles,
where
hehoped
to
make
aliving
inthe
film
business.Over
thenextfew
yearsBrechtwrotescreenplays
withapointedly
an—ticapitalist
slant.HehadlittlesuccessinHollywood,
soin
1947,
thewarhaving
ended,
hedecidedtoreturntoEurope.
Thatsame
year,
however,theUS.
Cong;ress’sHouseUn—AmericanActivitiesCommitteebegan
itsinvestigation
intosupposed
Communist
infiltration
inHollywood.
Itbegan
togather
informationonBrecht,
whohadsoopenlyespousedMarxism,
andonSeptember
19,1947,
only
amonthbeforehehadplanned
toleavetheUnited
States,
hereceivedasubpoena
to
appearbeforethecommittee.In
addition
to
Brecht,anumberofother
writers,producers,
anddirectorsweresummonedto
appearas
well,andthis
groupcame
tobe
knownastheHollywood
19.Before
goingtoWashington,
theHollywood
19 mettodecideona
plan
ofaction.Theirapproach
wouldbeconfrontational.Insteadof
answeringquestions
abouttheirmembership,
orlackof
it,intheCommunistParty,
they
wouldreadprepared
statements
that
wouldchallenge
theauthority
ofthecommittee
and
arguethatitsactivitieswereunconstitutional.Evenifthisstrategy
meantimprisonment,
itwould
gainpublicity
fortheircause.Brechtdisagreed.
Whatgood
was
it,heasked,
toplay
the
martyrandgain
alittlepublicsympathy
ifintheprocessthey
losttheability
to
stagetheirplays
andselltheirscripts
for
yearsto
come?Hefeltcertainthey
wereVoltaire
was
living
inexileinLondonat:1timewhenuntifrenclr3.-enrimem
wasinits
highest.One
daywalkingI/trough
thestreets,
he
foundhimselfsummnderl
byantmgrycrowd.
“Ilrmghim.
Ilzmg
theFrenchman,”
llzagvyelled.
Voltaire
calmlyadrlrresmrlthemobwiththe
following
words:"Men
ofEngland/Youwishtokillmt‘becauseIamaFrmchman.AmIno:
ymnirhedenoughinnot
Ming
hamanEirgléxhmarz?
"
T/tr:crowdcharred/zisthoughtfulwnrrlx,
andescortedhim
safelyback
m
his
lodgings.ins,
LITTLE.
BROWNnoonor
m+:n)o'rF.s.CI.lF'l'().\'
FADIMAN,I-.t)..1985LAW 22 I65