B2| Saturday/Sunday, March 14 - 15, 2020 **** THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
THE SCORE
THE BUSINESS WEEK IN 14 STOCKS
OCCIDENTAL PETROLEUM CORP.
The novel coronavirus is suppressing demand for oil
as the industry weathers a price war. In response,
Occidental Petroleum said Tuesday it will slash
spending and dividends. Companies with high debt
levels like Occidental, which bought rival Anadarko Petroleum
Corp. for $38 billion last year, are particularly vulnerable be-
cause Wall Street isn’t inclined to rescue them. Shares in Oc-
cidentalgained 15% Tuesdayfollowing the announcement.
OXY
15%
PERFORMANCEOFENERGY STOCKS
Source: FactSet
0
- 30
%
Occidental
Petroleum
Chevron
Exxon
Mobil
Mon. Tues. Wed. Thurs. Fri.
Your 401(k) May Do
A Bit Better This Time
Losses in near-retirement target-date funds are
less serious than in the financial crisis—so far
RETIREMENT|ANNE TERGESEN
PHOTO ILLUSTRATION BY EMIL LENDOF/WSJ; PHOTOS: ISTOCK
the end of 2019. The funds have
become staples in workplace re-
tirement plans thanks to a 2006
law that sanctions their use as de-
fault investments for employees
who are automatically enrolled.
Target-date funds for people
close to retirement “are holding up
better, which is important given
that this is when nest eggs are
biggest and it’s really important to
preserve them,” Mr. Acheson said.
The spread of automatic enroll-
ment has driven a surge into these
funds. They accounted for 37% of
the assets in 401(k)-style plans
Vanguard Group administered in
2019, up from 12% in 2010. Target-
date funds attracted 59% of new
contributions to 401(k)-style plans
last year, according to data on
plans Vanguard administers.
LIVE NATION
ENTERTAINMENT INC.
The concert industry is brac-
ing for a rough year as coro-
navirus stands to threaten its
critical summer season. Live
Nation Entertainment, the
world’s largest concert promoter, and ri-
val Anschutz Entertainment Group are
postponing shows at arenas, The Wall
Street Journal reported late Thursday.
Various cities and states have banned
gatherings of certain sizes. The
Coachella Valley Music and Arts Festival,
initially slated for April, was also post-
poned six months, while big-name art-
ists such as and Cher have called off
tours. Sharesgained 18% Friday.
LYV
18%
AMAZON.COM INC.
Some Amazon sellers have
been taking advantage of cor-
onavirus panic as anxious
shoppers turn online for face
masks, hand sanitizer and
other products that are be-
coming hard to find. Amazon has said it
has removed 530 , 000 offers and sus-
pended 2 , 500 accounts because of coro-
navirus-related price gouging, and re-
moved millions of products that make
unsupported claims about the coronavi-
rus. Other online marketplaces such as
eBay Inc. and Facebook Inc. have fea-
tured similarly high prices and question-
able products. Amazon.com sharesfell
3.8% Wednesday.
AMZN
3.8%
FIAT CHRYSLER
AUTOMOBILES NV
Italy’s coronavirus outbreak is
hitting that country’s big
manufacturers. Fiat Chrysler
Automobiles said Wednesday
it will lower production and
boost efforts to contain the spread of
the virus, including intensive sanitization
of work and rest areas, changing rooms
and washrooms. The auto giant has fac-
tories across Italy, including several in
the part of the country hardest hit by
the virus. Since last month, the com-
pany has asked most office-based em-
ployees to work from home and it says
all administrative work has proceeded
as normal. Sharesfell 3.6% Wednesday
FCAU
3.6%
AMERICAN AIRLINES GROUP
INC.
Airlines are cutting flights,
parking planes, freezing hiring
and reducing executive pay.
American Airlines said it
plans to cut domestic flying
by 7. 5 % and reduce international flying
by 10 % for the summer peak travel sea-
son. Coronavirus’s rapid impact on de-
mand has sent airlines reeling, and the
companies are preparing for the pros-
pect that recovery could take months,
rather than the quick bounceback many
first anticipated. To reduce costs, airlines
have started offering voluntary unpaid
leave to employees. American Airlines
sharesadded 15% Tuesday.
AAL
15%
CARNIVAL CORP.
Princess Cruises canceled all
its voyages for the next two
months and will cut short
some current trips, after two
of its ships suffered coronavi-
rus outbreaks. The Carnival-
owned cruise line is the first ocean car-
rier to suspend sailings as a result of
the new coronavirus. The suspension ap-
plies to voyages departing March 12 to
May 10 , Princess said Thursday. Current
trips with less than five days remaining
will continue, but those extending be-
yond March 17 will be cut short. The
cruise operator and the industry have
suffered greatly from the pandemic. Car-
nival sharesfell 31% Thursday.
CCL
31%
WALT DISNEY CO.
The happiest place on Earth
is shutting down as coronavi-
rus spreads. Walt Disney an-
nounced late Thursday it is
closing its Disneyland Resort,
Walt Disney World Resort
and Disneyland Paris through the end of
the month. Earlier that day, California
imposed a ban on public gatherings of
more than 250 , exempting movie the-
aters, theme parks and casinos. Disney
is also suspending new departures for
its Disney Cruise Line beginning Satur-
day and lasting at least until the end of
the month. The company said it will
continue to pay cast members. Disney
sharesadded 12% Friday.
DIS
12%
FACEBOOK INC.
The European Union is reviv-
ing an alliance formed last
year with U.S. tech compa-
nies to combat online political
disinformation. Its new focus:
false coronavirus information.
The European Commission, the bloc’s
executive body, has renewed a self-re-
porting system it created with Facebook,
Alphabet Inc.’s Google, Microsoft Corp.,
Twitter Inc. and Mozilla Corp. to ensure
that measures against disinformation
about the novel coronavirus are shared
quickly with the commission. The tech
companies promised to take down con-
tent deemed harmful to public health.
Facebook sharesfell 9.3% Thursday.
FB
9.3%
SLACK TECHNOLOGIES
The spreading coronavirus is
providing more business for
Slack. The company said late
Thursday that the global fall-
out from the pandemic is re-
sulting in a surge of interest
in its workplace-collaboration software,
though the impact isn’t reflected in its
fiscal 2020 earnings. Slack is seeing a
rush in free use of its service, but a
global slowdown in travel over virus
concerns could make it harder to close
new deals, said Allen Shim, the com-
pany’s chief financial officer. Slack’s
earnings outlook reflected that uncer-
tainty, Mr. Shim said. Sharesfell 8.2%
Friday.
WORK
8.2%
STARBUCKS CORP.
Not everyone can work from
home. U.S. food service work-
ers at chains like Starbucks
risk exposure to the novel
coronavirus and face pressure
to keep stores cleaner than
ever to reassure customers. Starbucks
said Wednesday it would pay any U.S.
workers in a 14 -day quarantine after ex-
posure to the coronavirus, as well as all
employees who are over 60 years old,
pregnant or have underlying health con-
ditions. The pandemic is already weigh-
ing on Starbucks’s bottom line after the
company temporarily shut down or lim-
ited hours at stores abroad. Starbucks
sharesfell 9.1% Thursday.
SBUX
9.1%
BANK OF AMERICA CORP.
Calming words from leaders of the biggest U.S.
banks failed to reassure investors as the stock
market officially entered bear territory. During a
White House meeting on Wednesday, attendees
from Bank of America, Citigroup Inc. and others said the
banks are in good shape despite the recent market turmoil.
The meeting failed to halt investor doubts, and Bank of
America sharesfell 9.5% Thursday.
BAC
9.5%
PERFORMANCEOFBANK STOCKS
Source: FactSet
0
- 35
- 30
%
Bank of
America
Citigroup
Goldman
Sachs
Mon. Tues. Wed. Thurs. Fri.
XEROX HOLDINGS CORP.
Xerox is taking a pause in its
campaign to take over HP
Inc., a sign that the coronavi-
rus pandemic is affecting deal
making. The company said
Friday that it is postponing
additional presentations, interviews with
the press and meetings with HP share-
holders. “Xerox needs to prioritize health
and safety of its employees, customers,
partners and affiliates over and above
all considerations,” Xerox Vice Chairman
and Chief Executive John Visentin said.
Both companies’ shares have fallen this
year as equities plunged into the bear
market on coronavirus concerns. Xerox
sharesgained 0.3% Friday.
XRX
0.3%
BROADCOM INC.
Broadcom pulled its financial
projections for the year, citing
uncertainty around the coro-
navirus pandemic. Instead,
the chip maker offered a rev-
enue forecast for the current
quarter, saying it expected revenue of
$ 5. 7 billion, falling short of analysts’
projections. Apple Inc., which accounted
for roughly 20 % of Broadcom’s revenue
last year, warned last month that it
would likely fall short of quarterly reve-
nue projections. Broadcom also said
Thursday that it would push debt pay-
ments to the second half of the year or
earlier if conditions improve. Sharesfell
11% Thursday.
AVGO
11%
LVMH MOET HENNESSY
LOUIS VUITTON SE
First China’s coronavirus out-
break weighed on demand
for luxury goods. Now Italy’s
outbreak could weigh on pro-
duction. Companies such as
LVMH Moët Hennessy Louis Vuitton are
straining to keep factories open while
adopting precautionary measures to
fight the spread of the disease in its
ranks. The makers of luxury goods are
providing workers with protective gear,
closing workplace cafeterias and warn-
ing employees to keep their distance
from each other. American depositary
shares of LVMHfell 6.3% Wednesday.
—Francesca Fontana
LVMUY
6.3%
In 2008, investors
were shaken when
many in or near re-
tirement saw a sig-
nificant percentage
of their 401(k) bal-
ances disappear.
Even those in so-called target-date
funds, generally designed to mini-
mize large swings close to retire-
ment, saw losses of 25% or more.
This time, amid fears of a global
economic slowdown tied to the
spread of the coronavirus, the hit
to those investors hasn’t been
nearly as large. That is, so far. It’s
still impossible to know how much
more damage we might be in for.
During the 2008 financial melt-
down, target-date portfolios for
people planning to retire by 2010
plunged by 36% on average from
the market’s precrisis peak on Oct.
9, 2007, to March 9, 2009, when
stocks began to rebound, accord-
ing to Morningstar Direct, a data-
base from Morningstar Inc. In con-
trast, from Feb. 20 through
Thursday, such portfolios for peo-
ple planning to retire in 2020 fell
close to 13%, on average.
From Feb. 20 through Thursday,
the S&P 500 stock index declined
27%. Friday’s rebound reduced the
drop to about 20%. The index fell
55% over the financial crisis.
During the financial crisis, the
36% loss by near-retirees in target-
date funds represented more than
two-thirds of the 53% decline suf-
fered by workers who were 30
years from retirement. By con-
trast, losses by people close to re-
tirement today are about half of
the 24% decline posted by funds
for workers who expect to retire
around 2050.
Over the past decade, due in
part to lessons learned during the
financial crisis, “the target-date
fund industry has matured signifi-
cantly,” said Leo Acheson, a direc-
tor at Morningstar.
Target-date funds, which take
an increasingly conservative ap-
proach as you near retirement age,
held about $2.3 trillion in assets at
As they have become more pop-
ular, these funds have also become
“more homogenous,” Mr. Acheson
said. In 2008, funds with similar
target dates posted widely diver-
gent results due, in part, to differ-
ing approaches to risk manage-
ment. While a 2010 fund in a
series from Wells Fargo that in-
vested conservatively lost 11% that
year, for example, the Oppen-
heimer Transition 2010 fund—sad-
dled with soured bets on mort-
gage-backed securities—sank 41%.
Since then, the performance gap
has narrowed considerably,
amounting to about 13 percentage
points for 2020 portfolios during
the recent stock-market selloff
through Thursday, according to
Morningstar. While the Putnam
RetirementReady 2020 fund lost
4.63% between Feb. 20 and March
12, the T. Rowe Price Retirement
2020 fund—which has a signifi-
cantly higher allocation to stocks—
declined 17% in that period.
Many target-date funds are de-
signed for people to stay in after
retirement. Joe Martel, a target-
date portfolio specialist at T. Rowe
Price Group Inc., said target-date
funds are “meant to be held for
decades.” The company believes
“the level of equity in our target-
date funds is necessary to help in-
vestors overcome the risk of run-
ning out of money in retirement.”
Many target-date funds have re-
vamped their approaches to man-
aging risk since 2008, said Mr.
Acheson. Portfolios closest to re-
tirement have an average of 45%
in stocks now, down from 50% in
2009, according to Morningstar.
With more assets flowing into
index-based target-date funds,
fewer managers are making large
bets that may result in perfor-
mance that significantly differs
from the benchmarks, said Brian
Miller, a senior product manager
in Vanguard’s portfolio-review de-
partment. He noted that some of
the funds that fared poorly in
2008, including the Oppenheimer
Transition funds, are now gone.
Internet Explorer web browser
with Windows, at one point rais-
ing the prospect of the company
being broken up on antitrust
grounds.
The eventual settlement with
the Justice Department placed
limits on how Microsoft operates
but kept the software giant in-
tact.
The success of Windows
helped turn Mr. Gates, a Harvard
University dropout, into one of
the world’s richest people. He has
plowed some of that wealth into
his foundation and other philan-
thropic causes.
Mr. Gates in 2008 scaled back
involvement in day-to-day opera-
tions of Microsoft, focusing more
on work the Bill & Melinda Gates
Foundation.
In 2014, when Mr. Nadella was
appointed CEO of the company,
Mr. Gates stepped down as chair-
man but stayed on as a board
member and technology adviser.
He continued to influence strate-
gic decisions at Microsoft and
visit its offices.
James Whittaker, a former dis-
tinguished engineer at Microsoft
who left the company in 2019,
said Mr. Gates continued to show
up at Microsoft’s campus once or
twice a month. He would fre-
quently weigh in on issues affect-
ing the company. “Whatever Bill
says becomes law,” Mr. Whittaker
said.
Berkshire Hathaway Chairman
and CEO Warren Buffett said for-
mer American Express Co. CEO
Kenneth Chenault would replace
Mr. Gates on the conglomerate’s
board.
Continued from page B
Gates Exits
Microsoft
Board