Hellenistic Philosophy Introductory

(Marvins-Underground-K-12) #1

180 l/-78 to l/-83


motion [or change]. Zeno of Citium called fate a power capable of moving
matter, and gave to the same [force] the names providence and nature.
His successors said that fate was a rational principle for the things adminis-
tered by providence within the cosmos, and again in other treatises they
called fate a string of causes.


Aetius 1.28.4 (= Dox. Gr. p. 324; SVF 2.917) [11-79]


The Stoics say it is a string of causes, i.e., an ordering and connection
which is inescapable.


Alexander De Anima Mantissa CIAG Supp.
2.1 p. 185.1-5 (SVF 2.920)


[11-80]

But it is conceded that all things which happen by fate occur in a
certain order and sequence and have an element of logical consequence
in them ... Anyway, they say that fate is a string of causes.


Plutarch Stoic Self-Contradictions. 34,
1049f-1050d (SVF 2.937)


[11-81]

(1049£) But nevertheless one will have not just one or two occasions
but thousands, to address to Chrysippus this remark, which is now
praised: "You have said the easiest thing, in blaming the gods." For first,
in book one of his Physics he compares the eternity of motion to a posset^36
which spins and agitates the various things which come to pass in various
ways; then he says: (1050a) "Since the organization of the universe
proceeds thus, it is necessary for us to be such as we are, in accordance
with it, whether we are ill or lame, contrary to our individual nature, or
whether we have turned out to be grammarians or musicians." And again,
a bit further on: "and on this principle we will say similar things about
our virtue and our vice and, in general, about our skills or lack of them,
as I have said". And a bit further on, removing all ambiguity: "for it is
impossible for any of the parts, even the smallest one, to turn out differ-
ently than according to the common nature and its reason". That the
common nature and the (1050b) common reason of nature are fate and
providence and Zeus, even the Antipodeans know this; for the Stoics
prattle on about this everywhere and he says that Homer correctly said^37
"and Zeus' plan was being fulfilled", referring it to fate and the nature
of the universe according to which everything is ordered.



  1. A drink composed of a suspension of solid particles in a fluid base.

  2. Iliad 1.5.

Free download pdf