The Drawings of Michelangelo and His Followers in the Ashmolean Museum

P 1 : JZP
0521551335 apx 2 a CUNY 160 /Joannides 052155 133 1 January 11 , 2007 14 : 21

APPENDIX 2. THE LAWRENCE COLLECTION OF DRAWINGS 433

low price which strongly suggests that it was recognised as a

copy.

35. 1836 - 96 /184 2- 22 /R. 13 /P.II 323 /Cat. 28.


36. 1836 - 83 / 1838 - 48 / 1850 - 13 0,asSebastiano del Piombo/
    186 0- 112 /BM W 16.


37. 1836 - 79 / 1838 - 46 / 1850 - 142 ?/186 0- 100 bought Tiffin/
    Locker[-Lampson]/BM W 11.


38. 1836 - 76 /184 2- 28 [sic, for 29 ]/ R. 37 /P.II34 2/Cat. 40.


39. 1836 - 15 / 1838 - 4 / 1850 - 101 /BM W 42.
    40.This drawing is no doubt identical with that in the Julien
    de Parme Sale of 21 – 22 February 1794 , lot 10 :

michel-ange buonarotti

Une Descente de Croix, composition de quatre figures pre-

ciusement dessinees ́ `alapierre noire; on y joindra l’estampe

grav ́ee par Bonasone.

According to the 1836 catalogue, which does not men-

tion Julien de Parme, this drawing was subsequently owned

byBrunet (For discussion of the Brunet issue, see com-

mentary to 1830 - 21 ). 1836 - 64 / 1838 - 35 / 1850 - 18 0/186 0- 119 ,

bought by Enson, £ 52. 10 s/Brooks Collection/F. T. Pal-

grave Collection, sold Christie’s, 4 June 1886 , bought by

J. C.Robinson/Agnews, London/Acquired by Mrs. Gard-

ner in 1902 for the Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum,

Boston.

41. 1836 - 73 / 1838 - 41 / 1850 - 15 8/Lawrence Gallery, 1853 , pl. 4 /
    186 0- 104 /BM W 58.


42. 1836 - 85 / 1838 - 50 / 1850 - 167 /186 0- 110 /Bayonne Musee ́
    Bonnat, Bean 65.


43. 1836 - 43 / 1838 - 23 / 1850 - 151 , bought Engelbert/Frankfurt,
    St ̈adelsches Kunstinstitut, Inv. 399 ,bySebastiano del
    Piombo. Malke, 1980 ,no. 87 , established the pre-
    Richardson provenance of this sheet as Padre Resta whose
    number k 67 it bears.


44. 1836 - 87 / 1838 - 52 / 1850 - 13 0,asSebastiano del Piombo/
    Lawrence Gallery, 1853 , pl. 12 /186 0- 111 , bought Farrer/BM
    W 17.


45. 
    

    i. 1836 - 62 / 1838 - 33 / 1850 - 122 /Lawrence Gallery, 1853 , pl.
    11 /186 0- 121 /BM W 52.
    ii.186 0- 270 /Probably Frankfurt, St ̈adelsches Kunstinsti-
    tut, Inv. 3975 .Perhaps by Alessandro Allori rather than
    Clovio.
    46.This item is puzzling. It would be easy to assume that
    it was a drawing made for theLast Judgement,but no other
    instance can be found in the 1830 inventory of the word
    “cartoon” used to describe a preparatory drawing. The

    
    

present work cannot be the Taddeo Zucaro cartoon, already

described as 1830 - 1. There remains the possibility that it may

be186 0-15 9, bought by Ripp for £ 1. 15 s. If so, the facts that

it did not appear in the 1836 exhibition, cannot be traced

in the collection of William II of Holland, and presumably

was not sold to him, and was not offered to Oxford, suggests

that it was soon judged to be much less significant than its

1830 listing would suggest. This would also be borne out by

the low price that it realised in186 0.

47.Probably 1836 - 27 / 1838 - 12 / 1850 - 105 /186 0- 115 /Malcolm

73 /BM W 81.

48. 1836 - 25 / 1838 - 10 / 1850 - 171 /186 0- 116 /Malcolm 73 /BM
    W 82.


49. 1836 - 28 / 1838 - 13 / 1850 - 15 2/Lawrence Gallery, 1853 , pl. 9 /
    186 0- 114 /Count Antoine Seilern/London, Courtauld Insti-
    tute of Art, Prince’s Gate Collection.


50. 1836 - 23 /184 2- 38 /R. 72 /P.II 343 /Cat. 57.


51. 
    

    i. 1836 - 54 /184 2- 39 /R. 31 /P.II 324 /Cat. 23.
    ii.Sotheby’s, 18 February 1991 , lot15 9.

    
    

52.Reproduced by Ottley,Italian School,f.p. 32 / 1814 -

262 , bought by Roscoe/ 1836 - 63 / 1838 - 34 / 1850 - 15 4 (the

subject misidentified as the Virgin and Child)/186 0- 136 /

Vaughan/BM W 29. See 1814 - 262 and 1850 - 15 4for further

details.

53.i,ii,iii,iv. 1836 - 50 /184 2- 66 /R. 25 /P.II 303 - 306 /Cats.

13 – 16.

54. 1836 - 89 /184 2- 21 /R. 23 /P.II 297 /Cat. 18.


55. 1836 - 74 / 1838 - 42 / 1850 - 107 /186 0- 134 /BM W 57.
    56.Probably 1836 - 70 / 1838 - 39 / 1850 - 147 , bought by Roos,
    115 guilders/Weimar, Sachsen Weimar Collection (Von
    Ritgen photograph, 1865 ,no. 6 as Michelangelo; Brinck-
    mann, 1925 ,no. 97 )/Present whereabouts unknown.


56. 1814 - 829 / 1836 - 68 /184 2- 34 /R. 28 /P.II 361 /Cat. 91.


57. 1836 - 32 /184 2- 11 /R. 29 /P.II 318 /Cat. 34.
    59.184 2- 68 /R. 68 /P.II 357 /Cat. 87.

60.Reproduced by Ottley,Italian School,f.p. 33 / 1814 - 1768 /

1836 - 84 / 1838 - 49 / 1850 - 103 /186 0- 125 /E. Galichon, his sale,

May 1875 , lot. 16 /Malcolm 80 /BM W 60.

61 i,ii,iii,iv. 1814 - 264 / 1814 - 265 / 1836 - 2 /184 2- 47 /R. 24 /P.II

299 - 302 /Cats. 9 – 12.

62.184 2- 78 /R. 58 /P.II 330 /Cat. 42.

63. 1836 - 37 / 1838 - 18 / 1850 - 162 /186 0- 146 /Robinson/Mal-
    colm 60 /BM W 13.