13 Policy Matters.qxp

(Rick Simeone) #1

TThe origins of modern conservation


thought are deep and complex, but the
colonial roots of much twentieth century
thinking are widely recognised.^1 There
were, for example, important colonial con-
cerns about deforestation, climate change
and drought from the eigh-
teenth century onwards,
and game and forest
reserves were created in a
number of places.^2 Above
all, however, it was the
Victorian enthusiasm for
hunting, and the heritage of
British traditions of elite
landowning and ‘game man-
agement’, that gave conser-
vation its familiar shape.
From such ideas the essen-
tially preservationist
approach of the protected area became the
dominant conservation concept of the twen-
tieth century.^3

As formal wildlife conservation was estab-
lished towards the end of the nineteenth
century in African territories, it drew closely
on the European tradition of aristocratic
hunting, with beasts reserved for the King
and his lords, in descending order of priori-
ty. In Victorian Britain, the shooting of
pheasants, grouse and red deer, and the

chasing of foxes with packs of dogs,
became vital rituals of the landowning class,
a mark of social achievement and the mark-
ers of a shared culture.^4 In Scotland, the
Highland Clearances from the 19th century
onwards had driven smallholders to news
lands in North America, creating the very
real human emptiness celebrated by today’s
‘wilderness’ enthusiasts. Victorian landown-
ers hunted red deer in the barren hills they
left behind^5. Hunting in British colonial terri-
tories, especially in Africa and India, was
tied-in by connections of class and wealth
to this British Victorian world. In India, for
example, the British took over and adapted
elite Mughal hunting practices, especially
tiger shooting from elephant back and the
use of beaters. They added to them sports
such as pig sticking, and they exported their
enthusiasm for fox hunting as a sporting
activity to India, Australia and parts of
Africa.

An enthusiasm for hunting was by no
means confined to the elite of the British
Empire. It was shared by those newly
wealthy from industrialisation in the USA.
From the 1860s, wealthy young men from
rich eastern industrial families had begun to
frequent the Adirondacks to engage in the
masculine pastimes of shooting and fishing.
Their approach was an odd combination of
British upper-class tradition and an attempt

History, cculture aand cconservation


Colonialism, hhunting aand tthe iinvention oof ““poaching”


in tthe 119 th and 220 th^ Centuries


William MM. AAdams


Summary.The development of ideas about conservation in the twentieth century was greatly influ-
enced by colonial ideas about hunting. This paper discusses the significance of hunting to conservation
ideas in colonial Africa, and the sometimes rather mixed ideas about poaching and hunting by Africans. It
draws out the similarities between such debates and the contemporary discussion of community-oriented
versus strict conservation strategies. It argues that arguments about narrative change in conservation
need to take account of the diversity of ideas about people and nature, both in the past and today.


Above aall, iit wwas
the VVictorian
enthusiasm ffor
hunting, aand tthe
heritage oof BBritish
traditions oof eelite
landowning aand
‘game mmanage-
ment’, tthat ggave
conservation iits
familiar sshape.
Free download pdf